The study aimed to investigate the enhancement of internet on the effectiveness of ownership concentration, which is one of the corporate governance mechanisms, and consequently on the participation of a wide segment of shareholders in decision-making, thereby reflecting on institutional performance and contributing to reducing the agency problem gap in the business environment of banking institutions listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange. The problem can be posed as follows: Do the currently applied governance mechanisms contribute to reducing the severity of the agency gap between management and investors, and has the internet contributed to enhancing the effectiveness of applying governance mechanisms (ownership concentration) and thus contributes to reducing the severity of the impact of the Corona pandemic and management's exploitation of emergency situations and protecting investors? The sample included (21) banks listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange for the period before the pandemic, i.e. 2019, and the pandemic period in 2020, which was characterized by long periods of lockdown and quarantine, necessitating the use of social media to compensate for that. The study found that the impact of ownership concentration on return on assets for 2019 reached (0.124), which is a non-significant regression, and in 2020 it reached (0.692), which is a significant regression, i.e. the impact increased by (0.568) during the pandemic period. Thus, social media has enhanced the effectiveness of ownership concentration, and this was reflected in institutional performance, thereby reducing the gap of agency conflicts.
Digital technologies are increasingly changing the nature of competition and generating externalities that affect society. Digitalization allows institutions to create significant economic value in shorter time periods by improving economies of scale, scope, and learning, leading to increased returns on capital. However, societal concerns arising from inequality, regulatory lapses, and lack of transparency and credibility pose significant challenges to effective corporate governance. As a result of the emergence of agency theory, specialists in the economic field have pointed out that there is no reason to believe that the management of the institution works absolutely in the interest of investors and stakeholders based on the theory that rational individuals are biased towards achieving their goals and maintaining their interests in exchange for the interests of investors, and thus conflicts arise between the management of the institution and investors, which is called the classic agency conflict, and represents the first type of agency conflict. In order to reduce the severity of the conflict through commitment to several mechanisms called corporate governance, as long as ownership concentration is focused as a governance mechanism in the hands of a group of owners, it will motivate and give them the influence to monitor the performance of the institution's management in a way that does not deviate from the contractual objectives. Corporate governance aims to achieve a balance between the interests of various stakeholders in the institution. Financial reporting is another key aspect of institutional management. As a result of successive changes and circumstances in the institutional environment, including increased competition intensity, financing problems, global crises and their reflection on the local business environment and agency conflicts and the accompanying opportunistic practices of management, emergencies represented by the Corona pandemic can affect the way institutions govern themselves, deal with socially responsible issues and achieve sustainability practices. Therefore, in this study we examine the role of the Internet in enhancing shareholders' ability to influence institutional performance during the Corona pandemic.
The study contributes to testing the relationship between ownership concentration as one of the corporate governance mechanisms and the Internet as a reinforcing variable for that mechanism during the Corona pandemic, thereby increasing the impact of ownership structure (ownership concentration) on institutional performance and thus reducing the gap of agency conflicts between management and shareholders in banking institutions listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange.
Thus, this study aims to investigate the enhancement of the Internet from the role of ownership concentration, which is one of the corporate governance mechanisms, and consequently on the participation of a wide segment of shareholders in decision-making and thus reflects on institutional performance and thus contributes to reducing the gap of agency problems in the business environment of banking institutions listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange. The problem can be posed through the following question:
Do the currently applied governance mechanisms contribute to reducing the severity of the agency gap between management and investors?
Does the Internet enhance the application of governance mechanisms and thus contribute to reducing the severity of the impact of the Corona pandemic and management's exploitation of emergency situations and protect investors?
The Research Hypotheses can be Posed as Follows:
First hypothesis: There is no impact between ownership concentration applied in Iraq before the pandemic and the variables, thus negatively affecting the agency conflict gap.
The Following Sub-Hypotheses Branch from it
H0: There is no impact between ownership concentration applied in Iraq and return on assets, thus negatively affecting the agency conflict gap.
H0: There is no impact between ownership concentration applied in Iraq and earnings per share, thus negatively affecting the agency conflict gap.
Second hypothesis: There is an impact between ownership concentration applied in Iraq using the Internet (social media) as a reinforcement during the pandemic and variables, thus positively affecting the agency conflict gap.
The following sub-hypotheses branch from it:
H0: There is an impact between ownership concentration applied in Iraq using the Internet (social media) as a reinforcement during the pandemic and return on assets, thus positively affecting the agency conflict gap.
H0: There is an impact between ownership concentration applied in Iraq using the Internet (social media) as a reinforcement during the pandemic and earnings per share, thus positively affecting the agency conflict gap.
Literature Review
Mutashar [1] sought to clarify the implications of the Corona pandemic for capital joint stock companies, seeking to prove the role of corporate governance principles in mitigating its repercussions. The results indicated that Corona pandemic hit companies as it hit all facilities of economic, social and health life and in almost all countries of the world which necessitated suspension of corporation’s activities. Thus, highlighting the role of governance principles in mitigating the impact of Corona pandemic on companies. A group of recommendations has been shown, including the need for all companies to adhere to the procedures set by the competent authorities to mitigate its effects on economic sectors because of the outbreak of Corona pandemic disease and to work on communication efficiency between responsible companies and their stakeholders using modern communications technology through several electronic applications. The Governorate continues until we get rid of this epidemic.
Sama et al. [2] One of the salient issues from Davis et al. was that heavy reliance on the digital economy tends to create stakeholder consequences and externalities, which traditional governance mechanisms are typically not able to address. The paper offered a stewardship-oriented conceptual framework for corporate governance in response to stakeholder issues around truthfulness, transparency, fair resource allocation and trust that arose from consumer-, employee- and other high-profile stakeholder-manager-level transgressions of digital business conduct. It critically examines the positive contribution of organizational leaders as models of virtuous stewardship in a hyper-connected world. This exploration re-conceptualizes the contemporary understanding of stewardship in the digital economy and relates it to four facets-virtue, which is a behavioral model of corporate governance with corresponding virtues including integrity, transparency, confidence and technological equity.
Klingsöhr [3] sought to demonstrate if particular corporate governance mechanisms assist listed institutions in their efforts to utilize performance during COVID-19. Data - sourced from institutions within the French SBF120, UK FTSE100 and German DAX100 indices - for only the years 2010 through 2020 were examined. We assume that institutions complying with the best practices in corporate governance, their institutional performance during the crisis is better. So that the explanatory variable for the study then is board size, CEO/chairman duality, board independence, board ownership and five largest shareholders to proxy corporate governance. Liu et al. discovered that the distance between CEO and chair of board roles as well as higher levels of board ownership assist institutions cope with the unexpected COVID19 financial shock better. Nevertheless, we must restrict the research results as they are based on observations of 2 complete crisis periods, but account only for the first two pandemic waves. So, the outcomes should be reevaluated when more info is ready.
Al-Ghamdi [4] seeks to test the effectiveness of governance in confronting the Corona pandemic on commercial institutions, and to examine the legal methods of corporate governance based on Saudi law. The legal adaptation to the Corona epidemic is what this researcher also explains, as well as how Kingdom of Saudi Arabia faced the epidemic on private sector. The research further details the key professional and ethical standards that could be enhanced to strengthen the performance of business institutions seeking to minimize corruption. The comparative analytical approach was adopted whereby the researcher shed light on the status of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia in confronting the repercussions of Corona pandemic through corporate governance (specific to) commercial enterprises in addition to exploring some experiences in other countries. However, the most important results are that those commercial institutions which apply governance principles will be able to face epidemics and crises as well as successfully overcome them. Then, the paper ends with a key recommendation that is the corporate governance system should be established for commercial institutions so that its articles become binding on all commercial institutions across Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.
Devy et al. [5] also addressed this the vision of good corporate governance as an institution during COVID-19. The finding reveals that good corporate governance implementation of the institutions seen as applying four principles are applied relatively well: transparency, accountability, responsibility and independence and fair. Excellent corporate governance implementation as institutional strategy during the Covid-19 pandemic is implemented properly, good appeal against it has an impact to institution by having more customers and members needing for financing.
Theoretical Framework
Good Corporate Governance
Institutions that apply governance contribute significantly to achieving economic well-being and sustainable development for their societies [6]. Governance means a set of mechanisms, policies and rules that regulate the relationship between internal and external parties in order to guarantee all rights of stakeholders. In addition, it works to achieve equality between interests from inside and outside the institution in providing the necessary information at the specified time and aims to work efficiently and effectively to achieve a higher value for the institution. In addition, it creates reassurance for shareholders, stakeholders and prospective investors in maximizing the returns achieved [7]. The term good corporate governance includes several aspects so that the institution can be classified as good. Good corporate governance means following disclosure and transparency processes in order to provide regulators, shareholders and the general public with accurate information about financial, operational and other aspects of information related to the institution that concern stakeholders [8]. Good corporate governance is an integral part of the company's existence as it enhances the bank's position and increases investor confidence by ensuring the company's commitment to high profit growth [9]. Although there is no universally accepted definition of what constitutes good governance, good governance can be defined as a regulatory law of best practices that sets standards to ensure responsible corporate behavior and defines the roles and responsibilities of management and the board of directors in ensuring that shareholder and stakeholder expectations are met [10,11,12].
Ownership Type
Concentration on ownership can be viewed according to who the owner is. Corporate insiders themselves act as agents of the institution owning shares. According to stewardship theory, managers increase performance levels to maximize stock returns since they are motivated to safeguard their shareholders’ interests and maintain continued survival of the institution [13]. Secondly, they attributed the increase in internal ownership to better match of interest between both parties: CEO and institutional performance. This commitment by management to preserve establishment prosperity will ensure that managers remain geared to their task in a financial crisis. Effective governance during crises was significantly sustained by the active presence of foreign or institutional investors as shareholders [14]. As opposed to strangers, analysts and experts are more easily susceptible to professional expertise than institutional investors who apply in managing their investment portfolio and this implicitly results in sophisticated decision-making during the periods of a crisis. An empirical justification, which has a positive relationship between institutional and foreign investors presence and good performance of their institutions [15,16].
Investors and Corporate Governance
The higher the level of implementation of good corporate governance practices will have positive impact on the market value of any institution. Markets that maximize value will enforce good corporate governance practices. In their study on the role of foreign institutional investors in enhancing corporate governance practices in weak institutional environments, found that institutions transfer good corporate governance standards to host country to offset the weak regulatory environment confronting emerging markets. Furthermore, the capacity of institutions to raise corporate governance levels in these contexts is under supervision via the law system of their home country; owners from nation-states with high-quality legal enforcement possess a higher capacity to elevate corporate governance standards in poor institutional environments. As a result, the cultural differences between business practitioners' home countries and host countries add to this relationship in a negative moderation fashion.
Impact of Corporate Governance on Institutional Performance
The use of financial ratios to predict the institution's position is one of the ways to judge the institution's ability to continue in the future, where the institution's continuity is measured through indicators related to liquidity, profitability and indebtedness [17]. Neralla [18] tested the impact of corporate governance structure on institutional performance, and his study found that high board size has a strong positive impact with return on assets and Tobin's Q on institutional performance, and this contributes to enhancing the decision-making process. It also found a statistically insignificant relationship between ROA, EPS and NPM with board independence, and found a positive correlation between board meetings and Tobin's Q performance indicators. These scenarios lead to enhanced corporate governance practices, and institutions are likely to apply appropriate corporate governance practices and thus lead to advanced effectiveness in institutional performance and reduced agency costs. Ghabri [19] tested the impact of the legal and institutional environment on the relationship between management and performance, whether the country's legal system and level of investor protection interacts with corporate governance at the institutional level and how this affects institutional performance. The interaction between institutions at the state level and the corporate governance system significantly affects their performance. Institutions operating in common law countries tend to show a positive evaluation effect and higher performance than institutions with a similar level of corporate governance operating in civil law countries. In other words, in common law countries, investor protection is more strongly associated with improved corporate governance with better institutional performance. However, institutions operating in civil law countries with weaker investor protection and a similar level of corporate governance tend to be exposed to a negative valuation effect.
Internet and Corporate Governance
The availability of information or transparency about corporate governance practices continues to be an issue with respect to corporate matters. Trained on governance practices, they must prove their legitimacy as a valuable economic agent and thus national level of economic development while attracting local and international investors [20]. This could raise the question of what affects transparency on corporate governance practices (mandatory and voluntary) over the internet [21]. More specifically, this research seeks to examine the determinants of both mandatory and voluntary information on corporate governance practices disseminated through their websites. Disclosure practice is more common in relation to general information. Institutional size and "listed status" positively affect information transparency about corporate governance practices, whereas financial leverage, liquidity, audit firm size and credit risk rating are negatively related to the level of corporate governance disclosure [22]. The role of information technology on the implementation of corporate governance mechanisms, business continuity, transparency and disclosure during the Covid-19 pandemic: A new perspective from Indonesia (2022) The findings of this study indicated that the part of information technology has a meaningful and positive effect on business continuity, transparency & disclosure. The lack of IT governance is reflecting on the corporate governance mechanisms ineffectiveness in terms of business continuity, transparency and disclosure due to no mediating effect of IT governance during the pandemic which indicates that, IT governance and its direct role as well indirectly through promoting transparency, disclosure and business continuity could decrease adverse consequences during any crisis. Open innovation, in contrast has receive significant interest over the years. The Internet is one of the most important components used in institutions that implement modern financial technology with its provision of state-of-the-art and diversified services to the customer, as well as its ability to obtain information more easily and at any requested time [23]. Opening the research and development process to external stakeholders has its benefit for technology institutions in terms of minimizing the risks within the institution when deviant management motives or asymmetry between different stakeholders interested in open innovation arise [24].
Impact of the Corona Pandemic and Corporate Governance Response
As is known, the world has changed because of recent global events at the planet’s level, and the Corona pandemic is likely to change our view of the world, the way we think and how we manage our lives. Despite the human tragedy of loss of life, broken families, affected communities, and economic and social changes caused by the pandemic, the lockdown will form a cultural legacy that will remain long in our memory and memories for future generations. The outbreak of the Corona pandemic was declared globally on March 11, 2020, and since then there have been doubts in all areas of life including business and personal life [25], followed by the development of Corona strains and then the emergence of new disease waves such as monkeypox and hemorrhagic fever and the existence of global fear of an outbreak of these diseases. While the world is still suffering from the effects of the Corona pandemic at this stage, no one knows what the final impact on countries, economies, health, social and environmental will be. It has created devastating problems in every corner of the world with a catastrophic impact on health, economy, education and individuals.
The COVID-19 pandemic prompted nations worldwide to seek support through various forms of international collaboration, recognizing that unity and cooperation are vital during crises. Faced with the potential long-term effects of the pandemic, countries need to focus on implementing robust administrative strategies and ensure the resilience of their financial systems [26]. The crisis has impacted both voluntary and mandatory disclosure practices by institutions, influencing the quality of financial and social accounting reports. Furthermore, the pandemic has reshaped how businesses approach social responsibility, sustainability practices, and corporate governance, highlighting the need to assess the role of accounting in this context [27]. Understanding these dynamics is essential to grasp the pandemic's true impact and develop strategies to mitigate it. The full effects may take years to unfold, but examining how the pandemic has influenced corporate governance and organizational performance is crucial. Despite the recurring nature of economic shocks at both micro and macro levels, academic research has intensified in addressing these issues. Governments, too, are striving to minimize the pandemic's impact through various policy measures. Even beyond the health crisis, the pandemic will significantly reshape the global economy, having accelerated three key trends: remote work and virtual interactions, the rise of e-commerce and digital transactions, and the expansion of automation and artificial intelligence [28].
Sivaprasad & Mathew [29] examined the relationship between the application of corporate governance and the pandemic crisis in the United Kingdom, with HSBC International Bank as a case study of the crisis: UK evidence. It investigates the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the institution and the study adopted a case study approach using content analysis using internal and external media in addition to annual reports to analyze the impact of the pandemic on governance applications. The study concluded that institutions must be flexible in difficult times, follow sustainable practices and pay attention to the well-being of their employees. It argues that institutions must address the adequacy of IT infrastructure and assess IT-related risks.
Golubeva [30] did not confirm government support as an important source of funding to support institutions considering the pandemic, and points to the importance of country-specific factors for institutional performance, including the level of economic development and corporate governance infrastructure. Khatib & Nour [31] assessed the impact of the Corona pandemic on corporate governance characteristics and institutional performance and concluded that the Corona pandemic has affected all institutional characteristics including institutional performance, governance structure, profits, liquidity and leverage level. However, the difference between the pre-pandemic period and during the Corona pandemic is not significant.
Impact of the Pandemic on Shareholders
As of March 31, 2020, global financial markets faced significant turbulence and uncertainty as shareholders were impacted by the pandemic, leading to a decline in stock prices. In response, the regulatory authority in the United Kingdom instructed institutions to halt dividend payments at the end of March 2020, allowing them to build capital reserves to cushion potential losses from the pandemic. This decision caused concern among shareholders, particularly those who rely on dividend income for their livelihood during the crisis. It is crucial that shareholders and owners have the right to be fully informed about the value of their investments. Institutions must communicate the ongoing and future impacts of the pandemic on shareholders' investments. Shareholders should be made aware of the institution's financial position, liquidity, and any operational challenges. Providing forward-looking information is essential to keep investors informed about developments and uncertainties surrounding the pandemic crisis [29].
Practical Aspect
Study Population and Sample: The study population consists of banking institutions listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange for the period from 2015 to 2019, numbering (21) institutions, for which complete financial data are available during the study period. The researcher will rely on the number of those who own a high percentage of shares as well as the total percentage of ownership concentration of major shareholders and the percentage owned by financial and other institutions in the institution's shares and the percentage owned by foreigners in the institution's shares to measure the mechanism of ownership structure concentration to know the extent of application of corporate governance. As for how to measure the good application of governance through the impact of these mechanisms in reducing the agency conflict gap through the variables of (earnings per share, and return on assets), and multiple regression coefficient statistical methods were relied upon to measure the impact of the relationship before the pandemic period, i.e. in 2019 and the pandemic period, i.e. 2020, which was characterized by lockdown periods and reliance on social media for communication and meetings as well as reporting. The following are the equations for each variable:
Earnings per share = NI / Number of Shares
Data Collection Method
The published financial reports of banking institutions listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange were relied upon for the period from 2015 to 2019 to calculate the study indicators.
Study Hypotheses
The results from the Table 1 shows that the value of Pearson's correlation coefficient between dependent variable and independent variables was a moderate value (0.555) with a corresponding determination coefficient value (0.308) and adjusted determination coefficient value ( 0.124), i.e., variance explain area for return on assets to independent variable is 12.4%.
The Table 2 represents the results of the ANOVA analysis to test the goodness of fit of the regression, and we do find that (p.value = 0.208), which is more than (0.01), so we accept that NULL hypothesis which is invalidity of regression.
The Table 3 presents Pearson's correlation coefficient between the dependent variable and the independent variables, it has reached a moderate value (0.870) of determinant coefficient value (0.757) and adjusted determinant coefficient value (0.692), i.e., independent variables explained 69.2% of variance occurred in return on assets.
The Table 4 is ANOVA analysis to test the significance of regression, we note that (sig) value = ( 0.000 ) it, less than ( 0.01 ), so we reject null hypothesis and accept alternate Hypothesis; which state that " the regression is significant or tasought to say there is an effect of independent variables on dependent variable and thus dependent variable can be predicted through these Independent variables'.
In the Table 5, Pearson's correlation coefficient(r) between dependent and independent variables reached a moderate value (0.440), where its corresponding coefficient of determination 193 and adjusted coefficient of determination (-0.021)(i.e.,independent variables explain only 2.1% variance occurred in earnings per share).
Table 1: There is no impact between ownership concentration and return on assets for 2019
2019 Model Summaryb | ||||
Model | R | R Square | Adjusted R Square | Std. Error of the Estimate |
1 | 0.555a | 0.308 | 0.124 | 0.007076720870000 |
a. Predictors: (Constant)The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * percentage (total concentration of major shareholders, number of those who own shares, b. Dependent Variable: ROA
Table 2: Anova
ANOVAa | ||||||
Model | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F | Sig. | |
1 | Regression | 0.000 | 4 | 0.000 | 1.672 | 0.208b |
Residual | 0.001 | 15 | 0.000 |
|
| |
Total | 0.001 | 19 |
|
|
| |
a. Dependent Variable: ROA, b. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * percentage (total concentration of major shareholders, number of those who own shares
Table 3: There is an impact between ownership concentration and return on assets for 2020
Model Summaryb | ||||
Model | R | R Square | Adjusted R Square | Std. Error of the Estimate |
1 | 0.870a | 0.757 | 0.692 | 0.008086331090000 |
a. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * concentration percentage, number of those who hold a high percentage of shares, b. Dependent Variable: ROA
Table 4: Anova
ANOVAa | ||||||
Model | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F | Sig. | |
1 | Regression | 0.003 | 4 | 0.001 | 11.678 | 0.000b |
Residual | 0.001 | 15 | 0.000 |
|
| |
Total | 0.004 | 19 |
|
|
| |
a. Dependent Variable: ROA, b. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * concentration percentage, the number of individuals holding a high percentage of shares
Table 5: There is no impact between ownership concentration and earnings per share for 2019
Model Summaryb | ||||
Model | R | R Square | Adjusted R Square | Std. Error of the Estimate |
1 | 0.440a | 0.194 | -0.021 | 0.020603623900000 |
a. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * percentage (total concentration of major shareholders, number of those who own shares, b. Dependent Variable: Profit per share (EPS)
Table 6: Anova
ANOVAa | ||||||
Model | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F | Sig. | |
1 | Regression | 0.002 | 4 | 0.000 | 0.901 | 0.488b |
Residual | 0.006 | 15 | 0.000 |
|
| |
Total | 0.008 | 19 |
|
|
| |
a. Dependent Variable: Profit per share (EPS), b. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * percentage (total concentration of major shareholders, number of those who own shares
Table 7: H0: There is an impact between ownership concentration and earnings per share for 2020
Model Summaryb | ||||
Model | R | R Square | Adjusted R Square | Std. Error of the Estimate |
1 | 0.843a | 0.710 | 0.633 | 0.023722257700000 |
a. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * concentration percentage, and the number of individuals holding a high percentage of shares, b. Dependent Variable: Profit per share (EPS)
Table 8: Anova
ANOVAa | ||||||
Model | Sum of Squares | df | Mean Square | F | Sig. | |
1 | Regression | 0.021 | 4 | .005 | 9.187 | .001b |
Residual | 0.008 | 15 | .001 |
|
| |
Total | 0.029 | 19 |
|
|
| |
a. Dependent Variable: Profit per share (EPS), b. Predictors: (Constant), The percentage of shares owned by foreigners in the institution, the percentage of shares owned by financial institutions in the institution, number * concentration percentage, and the number of individuals holding a high percentage of shares
The Table 6 displays the results of the ANOVA analysis that aims to test the significance for regression and we colorful noticed that its sig = (0.488) which is more than (0.01) then this leads us to accepting the null hypothesis here, and that is: `the regression isn't significant` thus there is no effect of independent variables on dependent variable however, we will not be able to predict the value for dependent variable through these independent variables.
As per the Table 7, Pearson's correlation coefficient between dependent variable & independent variables obtained a moderate value (0.843) with coefficient of determination value (0.710) and adjusted coefficient of determination value (0.633), i.e., independent variables explain 63% variance occurring in earnings per share.
It is measured by ANOVA analysis, the Table 8 demonstrates it results where as for the regreesion we have the sig = (0.001) < (0.01), thus the null hypothesis are rejected and the alternative hypothesis accpet, this indicates that in general regression is significant or there are impact from independent variable to dependent variable therefor we can predict dv using those IV.
We note that the impact of ownership concentration on return on assets for 2019 reached (0.124), which is a non-significant regression, and in 2020 it reached (0.692), which is a significant regression, i.e. the impact increased by (0.568) during the pandemic period. We also note that the impact of ownership concentration on earnings per share for 2019 reached (-0.021), which is a non-significant regression, and in 2020 it reached (0.633), which is a significant regression, i.e. the impact increased by (0.654) during the pandemic period. During the pandemic period, the internet was relied upon for communication and meetings. Thus, the internet has contributed to enhancing the role of ownership, concentration on institutional performance and thus reducing the gap of agency conflicts.
Recommendation
Our study recommends legislating laws that oblige institutions to hold in-person and electronic meetings and adopt electronic voting, as well as electronic disclosure of decisions to all shareholders via the internet.
Mutashar, S.S. "The Impact of the Corona Pandemic on Companies and the Role of Governance Principles in Reducing Them: An Analytical Study." Webology, vol. 19, no. 1, 2022, pp. 2824-2834.
Sama, L.M., et al. "Rethinking Corporate Governance in the Digital Economy: The Role of Stewardship." Business Horizons, vol. 65, no. 5, 2022, pp. 535-546.
Klingsöhr, E.F. "Corporate Governance and Financial Performance in Times of the Pandemic." Doctoral dissertation, Instituto Superior de Economia e Gestão, 2022.
Al-Ghamdi, O.D.A. "Commercial Corporates Governance in View of Challenges of the Corona Pandemic in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia." Journal of Economic, Administrative and Legal Sciences, vol. 5, no. 19, 2021, pp. 136-117.
Devy, H.S., et al. "Good Corporate Governance As A Corporate Strategy During the Covid-19 Pandemic in Islamic Financial Institutions." Mutanaqishah: Journal of Islamic Banking, vol. 1, no. 1, 2021, pp. 21-30.
Al-Salmani, Mutlak Hamad Mohammed. "The Added Value of Internal Auditing and Its Role in Achieving the Basic Pillars of Public Institutions Governance." Applied research in a sample of formations of the Ministry of Water Resources, Higher Institute of Accounting and Financial Studies, University of Baghdad, 2020, p. 31.
Hussein, Shameem Jamil. "The Role of Auditing in Determining the Relationship Between Governance of Investment Policy and Debt Costs and Its Reflection on the Continuity of Economic Units." Applied research, Higher Institute of Accounting and Financial Studies, University of Baghdad, 2022, p. 27.
Rustam, A.R., and Narsa, I. "Good Corporate Governance: A Case Study of Family Business in Indonesia." The Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, vol. 8, no. 5, 2021, pp. 69-79.
Aluqaidi, R.A. "The Impact of Corporate Governance on Banking Risk Management Business." Baghdad University Degree of Doctor, Thesis, 2019.
Adegbite, E. "Good Corporate Governance in Nigeria: Antecedents, Propositions, and Peculiarities." International Business Review, vol. 24, no. 2, 2015, pp. 319-330.
Fainshmidt, S., et al. "Varieties of Institutional Systems: A Contextual Taxonomy of Understudied Countries." Journal of World Business, vol. 53, no. 3, 2018, pp. 307-322.
Kabbach de Castro, L.R., et al. "Family Firms and Compliance: Reconciling the Conflicting Predictions Within the Socioemotional Wealth Perspective." Family Business Review, vol. 30, no. 2, 2017, pp. 137-159.
El-Chaarani, H., et al. "The Impact of Corporate Governance on the Financial Performance of the Banking Sector in the MENA Region: An Immunity Test of Banks for COVID-19." Journal of Risk and Financial Management, vol. 15, no. 2, 2022, p. 82.
Jebran, K., and Chen, S. "Can We Learn Lessons from the Past? COVID‐19 Crisis and Corporate Governance Responses." International Journal of Finance & Economics, 2021.
Georgantopoulos, A.G., and Filos, J. "Corporate Governance Mechanisms and Bank Performance: Evidence from the Greek Banks During Crisis Period." Investment Management and Financial Innovations, vol. 14, no. 1, 2017.
Anand, A., et al. "Institutional Trading and Stock Resiliency: Evidence from the 2007–2009 Financial Crisis." Journal of Financial Economics, vol. 108, no. 3, 2013, pp. 773-797.
Razuki, Muhannad Talib. "The Auditor's Role in Determining the Relationship Between the Practice of Accounting Conservatism and Financial Failure and Its Impact on Company Continuity." Applied research in a sample of companies listed on the Iraq Stock Exchange, Higher Institute of Accounting and Financial Studies, University of Baghdad, 2021, p. 51.
Neralla, N.G. "Can Corporate Governance Structure Affect Corporate Performance: An Empirical Investigation from Indian Companies." International Journal of Disclosure and Governance, 2022, pp. 1-19.
Ghabri, Y. "Legal Protection Systems, Corporate Governance and Firm Performance: A Cross-Country Comparison." Studies in Economics and Finance, 2022.
Engel, E., et al. Report of the Expert Advisory Group on Anti-Corruption, Transparency, and Integrity in Latin America and the Caribbean. Inter-American Development Bank, 2018.
Ovelar-Fernández, W.D., et al. "What Determines the Progress of Online Information Access to Banking Corporate Governance Practices? The Case of Paraguay." PLOS ONE, vol. 17, no. 1, 2022, e0262334.
Almaqtari, F.A., et al. "The Mediating Effect of IT Governance Between Corporate Governance Mechanisms, Business Continuity, and Transparency & Disclosure: An Empirical Study of the Covid-19 Pandemic in Jordan." Information Security Journal: A Global Perspective, 2022, pp. 1-19.
Hussein, Saif Ali. "The Impact of Financial Technology in Enhancing Financial Inclusion of the Iraqi Environment." Applied research in the Iraqi Central Agency, Higher Institute of Accounting and Financial Studies, University of Baghdad, 2021, p. 24.
Shaikh, I., and Randhawa, K. "Managing the Risks and Motivations of Technology Managers in Open Innovation: Bringing Stakeholder-Centric Corporate Governance into Focus." Technovation, vol. 114, 2022, 102437.
Koutoupis, A., et al. "Corporate Governance and COVID-19: A Literature Review." Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society, 2021.
Popescu, C.R.G. "Environmental, Social, and Corporate Governance by Avoiding Management Bias and Tax Minimization: Reaching a General Consensus Regarding a Minimum Global Tax Rate." In COVID-19 Pandemic Impact on New Economy Development and Societal Change, edited by A. Sarwar and M. Haroon, pp. 94-132. IGI Global, 2022.
Yu, A. "Accountability as Mourning: Accounting for Death in the Time of COVID-19." Accounting, Organizations and Society, vol. 90, 2021, 101198.
Lund, S., et al. "The Future of Work After COVID-19." McKinsey Global Institute, 2021, p. 18.
Sivaprasad, S., and Mathew, S. "Corporate Governance Practices and the Pandemic Crisis: UK Evidence." Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society, 2021.
Golubeva, O. "Firms' Performance During the COVID-19 Outbreak: International Evidence from 13 Countries." Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society, 2021.
Khatib, S.F., and Nour, A.N.I. "The Impact of Corporate Governance on Firm Performance During the COVID-19 Pandemic: Evidence from Malaysia." Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, vol. 8, no. 2, 2021, pp. 943-952.